Skip to main content

Why your network status may look wrong, and how to correct it

The difference between the network badge and the benefits tabs, the four usual causes of a wrong status, and how to fix both this breakdown and the next one.

C
Written by Cairo Murphy

Network status is the part of a breakdown offices catch us on most often. If a breakdown says you're in network when you're not, every percentage under it is wrong, and that costs you money at claim time. Here's how the status gets decided, why it goes wrong, and what to do about it.

Two things on the breakdown say "network," and they mean different things

This trips up almost everyone, so it's worth getting straight first.

  • The network status badge at the top is about your provider. It's answering: is this dentist in network with this payer, on this patient's plan?

  • The In Network and Out of Network tabs in the benefits section are about the plan. Every plan has both columns. Those tabs just show you what the plan pays either way.

The badge decides which tab you should be reading. So if the badge is wrong, you're reading the wrong column — and on a plan that pays nothing out of network, that's the difference between a covered visit and a full write-off.

Where the status comes from

It isn't a setting you flip once. Each breakdown works it out fresh, from whichever of these is available:

  • What the payer told us. On a full breakdown, this is what the rep said on the call or what the provider portal showed. This is the most common source.

  • An earlier breakdown for the same plan. If we've already verified this exact plan for your office, we may carry the network status forward rather than asking again.

  • Your own history. If your office has been consistently in or out of network with a payer across a lot of past breakdowns, we lean on that pattern.

  • A human reviewer. Someone on our team confirms the field before a full breakdown is completed.

The four reasons it's usually wrong

1. It ran under the wrong provider. This is the most common cause by far, and the easiest to miss. Every breakdown runs under one NPI. If the request didn't specify one, it falls back to your account's default provider. So if Dr. A is in network and Dr. B isn't, and everything runs under Dr. B by default, every breakdown comes back out of network — correctly, just for the wrong dentist.

Check the provider name on the breakdown first. If it isn't the treating dentist, that's your answer.

2. You're in network with the payer, but not on that plan. This is the second big one, and it's why "we're in network with MetLife" isn't a complete answer. Offices are routinely in network on one product and out on another — PDP versus PDP Plus, a federal plan versus a commercial one. Leased and umbrella networks make it worse: a breakdown can say you're in network through Connection Dental, DenteMax, Careington or a similar network you've never contracted with.

If the network or fee schedule named on the breakdown isn't one you're contracted with, say so specifically when you report it. "We have no contract with DenteMax, we're Connection Dental" is a fixable report. "The network status is wrong" is much slower.

3. The payer told us wrong. It happens. Reps misread their own screens, and portals sometimes report the status of whichever provider the login belongs to rather than yours. When we've got a call reference number we'll tell you exactly what the rep said and when, so you can take it back to the payer if you need to.

4. A wrong answer got repeated. Because we lean on your history, one wrong status that goes unreported can get carried into later breakdowns for the same plan. This is the best argument for flagging the first one you see instead of correcting it by hand and moving on.

How to correct one

Flag the field on the breakdown. Open the breakdown, find the network status field, and click the flag icon next to it. Enter the correct value. This is the single most useful thing you can do — a flag is treated as the highest-trust correction we have, above anything the payer or our own history said.

Then message support with the specifics. Give us the patient name, the payer, and what the status should be. Our operations team investigates and will re-run the breakdown for you with the correct status.

Ask for the credit. If a full breakdown was wrong and has to be re-run, ask us to credit it back. You shouldn't lose a breakdown from your allotment over our mistake, and we'll apply it as a credit on your next billing date.

Fixing it going forward

Record your standing for that provider and payer. On a breakdown, there's an Update Provider's Network Status button near the benefits tabs. It opens a short form where you set In or Out of Network for that provider and payer, pick a payer tier if the payer has them, and add free-text details.

Use that details box — it's where nuance lives. Something like "in network for everything except federal plans, which go through Connection Dental" is exactly the kind of note our team needs. Once saved, a green check appears on whichever benefits tab matches what you recorded.

Two honest caveats. Saving this does not change the breakdown you're looking at — flag the field for that. And it doesn't yet automatically correct your next breakdown; it's reference our team uses when working on your account.

Send us your full INN/OON list. Go to Settings, stay on the General tab, and scroll to Document Upload. Under INN/OON Network Status, click Upload File and send us a sheet listing every payer and network you're in network with, and every one you're out of network with.

A spreadsheet is ideal. It accepts CSV, Excel, Word and PDF files up to 50MB, one file at a time. Our team uses this when working on your account, and it's far better than us finding out payer by payer. Note that you won't be able to see or re-download the file afterwards, so keep your own copy — and send us a fresh one whenever your contracts change.

If you're out of network with everyone, say so. Some offices contract with nobody, and for those we can set the account so breakdowns default to out of network. Message support and ask.

Which provider a breakdown runs under

Since the wrong provider is the most common cause, it's worth checking this once — and this part you can fix yourself.

Go to Settings, then the NPIs tab. You'll see every provider on your account. From here you can:

  • Add a provider with Add New NPI — you'll need the NPI number and the provider's name.

  • Edit or remove a provider using the pencil and trash icons.

  • Set the default with the Set Default button. The provider carrying the green Default badge is the one used for one-click basic eligibility checks and for automated basic verifications.

If the default is the wrong dentist for most of your patients, changing it fixes a whole class of these reports at once.

You can also choose the provider per request. When you submit breakdowns, the submit window has an NPI Selection dropdown, pre-set to your default. If a patient is being seen by someone other than your default provider, switch it there before submitting and the breakdown comes back for the right dentist.

One caveat: if your practice management system is connected, your NPIs sync automatically from it, and manual changes here can be overwritten on the next sync. If a change won't stick, that's why — tell support and we'll sort it out at the source.

What to include when you report one

You'll get a much faster fix if you send all of this at once:

  • Patient name and the date you requested the breakdown

  • The payer, and the specific plan name if you have it

  • Which provider it should have run under

  • What the status should be, and how you know — a portal screenshot or a rep name and reference number is ideal

  • Whether it was a basic or a full breakdown

Did this answer your question?